According to the wittgensteinian theory of art, something is a work of art if it is designated as such within the institutions or ways of thinking that characterize social existence 20 followers of wittgenstein argue that in saying that art is an open concept , we mean that it is a commodity. The representations of these things on earth, according to plato, are just weak reflections of the perfect forms in the intelligible world he believes that the goal of a philosopher is to come to know and understand these forms. According to plato, demiurge creates the idea and by beholding the idea demiurge produces the object his ability is exalted in the imitation of the idea the poet, on the other hand, creates the images neither by seeing the idea nor from more substantive knowledge of the object since he produces nothing but phenomena by holding up a mirror. We therefore disagree with plato’s idea of art as imitation for which he dismisses art as useless according to him, that nature imitates art is two timid a .
Havelock linked parry's findings on the imitative nature of the formulaic patterns of homeric poetry with plato's criticism of the poets in the republic, and with the negative assessment of art in other dialogues. First and original is the level of god, who creates the bed as an idea second is the carpenter who imitates god's idea in making a particular bed and last is the poet or painter, whose bed imitates the imitator's. Although it was plato who first discussed the concept of imitative art, it is my belief that aristotle was justified in his praise and admiration of imitative art, specifically, the tragic drama show more. The status of art in plato's philosophy has always been a difficult problem as a matter of fact, he even threw the poets out from his ideal state, a passage that has led some interpreters to assess that plato did not develop a proper philosophy.
In ancient greece, mimesis was an idea that governed the creation of works of art, in particular, with correspondence to the physical world understood as a model for beauty, truth, and the good plato contrasted mimesis, or imitation , with diegesis , or narrative. A critical examination of plato’s ideas on imitation and inspiration in literature ideas in his definition of art reality lies with the idea the form one . The concept of imitation in plato and aristotle they have different views on the functions of imitation in art and literature plato believes in according to .
Art is imitation this is a feature of both of plato's theories of course he was not the first or the last person to think that art imitates reality of course he was not the first or the last person to think that art imitates reality. • plato‟s theory of mimesis, says by nature all art is mimetic it‟s an imitation of life • he considered „idea‟ as the ultimate reality and since art imitates idea it becomes imitation of reality • gave more credence to philosophy as philosophy deals with the ideas while poetry with illusion • thus to plato arts of all kind . Essay: art as imitation in plato and aristotle posted on january 9, 2013 by literaryfruit ancient greek thought held that poetry, drama, and other forms of fine art were imitations of reality, a reality that could be actual or potential. Art moves in a world of images, and reproduces the external, according to the idea or image in his mind thus the poet does not copy the external world, but creates according to his ‘idea’ of it thus even an ugly object well-imitated becomes a source of pleasure. Aristotle vs plato comparison aristotle and plato were philosophers in ancient greece who critically studied matters of ethics, science, politics, and more though many more of plato's works survived the centuries, aristotle's contributions have arguably been more influential, particul.
D is closely associated with the philosophy of art aesthetics studies new ways of seeing and of perceiving the world plato says that art imitates the objects . In his theory of mimesis, plato says that all art is mimetic by nature art is an imitation of life he believed that ‘idea’ is ultimate reality art imitates idea and so it is imitation of reality. Art imitates idea and so it is imitation of reality aristotle’s concept of tragedy according to aristotle metre/verse alone is not the distinguishing feature .
Plato’s theory of mimesis and aristotle’s defense in his theory of mimesis, plato says that all art is mimetic by nature art is an imitation of life he believed that ‘idea’ is the ultimate reality. For plato, art imitates a world that is already far removed from authentic reality, truth truth exists only in intellectual abstraction, that is, paradoxically, more real than concrete objects the universal essence, the idea, the form of a thing, is more real and thus more important than its physical substance. Aristotle’s theory of ‘poetic imitation’: salient features of theory of imitation and contrast with those of plato “art imitates nature” in ‘the . Plato said that art was imitation when an artist creates something, he is really imitating what is seen in nature when you draw or sculpt something, you are imitating the other.